REF·CARD
Panel verdict · upheld
Everton 2-0 Nottingham Forest
PREMIER LEAGUE · MW34 · 21 Apr 2024 · REF: A. TAYLOR
The argument
Ashley Young challenge on Giovanni Reyna — penalty not given
The panel ruled
The panel unanimously backed the referee.
No penalty — on-field call correct
Unanimous · 5-0
“the ball isn't played, there is contact by the defender on the attacker but any contact is minimal and is exaggerated by the attacker, and falls below the high threshold for a penalty.”
AT STAKE — A PENALTY APPEAL AT 0.79 xG · 24TH MINUTE · GOALLESS
Argued 21 Apr 2024 · ruled 29 Apr 2024
therefcard.comindependent panel verdict · fair to the referee